Jack Buess
- Graduation Class of 1937
- Participated in Football: Offensive & Defensive Tackle (3 letters)
- Basketball: Forward (2 letters)
- Conference Team Champions (1936 & 1937)
- Baseball: Outfielder (1 letter)
- Track & Field: Relays (1 letter)
Brian Burns
- Graduation Class of 2000
- Participated in Football: Tailback & Linebacker (3 letters)
- MAC-8 Conference MVP (1999)
- Division VI All Ohio (1999)
- Division VI Offensive Player of the Year (1999)
- 1st Team All-Conference (1998 & 1999)
- Holds School Records:
- Most Yards: Career (4622)
- Most Points: Career (454)
- Most Points: Game (36)
- Most Yards: Game (282)
- Most Touchdowns: Game (6)
- Team Captain (1999)
- MAC-8 Conference Team Champions (1999)
- Undefeated regular season record (10-0)
- Basketball: Forward (2 letters)
- 1st Team All-Conference (2000)
- Team Captain (2000)
- Track & Field: Sprinter (2 letters)
- Michigan State University – Full Scholarship
- Big Ten Conference – Scholar Athlete
Jennifer Nicastro
- Graduation Class of 2000
- Participated in Cross Country: (4 letters)
- 1st Team All-Conference (1996,1997, 1998, 1999)
- 1st Team All-Conference (1997, 1998, 1999, 2000)
- Team Most Valuable Performer (1998, 1999)
- Team Captain (1999)
- MAC-8 Conference Team Champions (1999)
- Soccer: (2 letters)
- 2nd Team All-Conference (1999)
- Track & Field: (4 letters)
- MAC-8 Conference MVP (2000)
- 1st Team All-Conference (1997, 1998, 1999, 2000)
- Team Most Valuable Performer (1998, 1999, 2000)
- Team Captain (2000)
- State Qualifier (2000)
- Holds School Record for 800 Meter Run (2:24.23)
- OHSAA Archie Griffin Sportsmanship Award
Nate Tarorick
- Graduation Class of 1993
- Participated in Football: Quarterback & Linebacker (3 letters)
- Division VI All Ohio (1992)
- MAC-8 Conference MVP (1992)
- 1st Team All-Conference (1992)
- Holds School Records:
- Assisted Tackles: Season (83)
- Fumble Recoveries: Season (10)
- MAC-8 Conference Team Co-Champions (1991)
- School Record for wins: 11-2 (1992)
- Regional Team Champions / State Final Four (1992)
- Basketball: Guard (2 letters)
- Baseball: Shortstop/2nd Base/ Pitcher (3 letters)
- 1st Team All-District: Division IV (1993)
- Division IV District Player of the Year (1993)
- Division VI 1st tem All Ohio (1993)
- 1st Team All-Conference (1993)
- Team Captain (1993)
- Team Most Valuable Performer (1992, 1993)
- Holds School Record for Most Doubles – Season: 11 (1993))
- OHSAA Archie Griffin Sportsmanship Award
- Cleveland Touchdown Club Scholar Athlete Award